You will submit annotated trades and use the feedback. The personalized response is the product; if you only watch live sessions passively, you are paying coaching prices for a stream.
View Jdub offer ↗Commission linkEducation head-to-head
Jdub Trades vs. RakeTrades
$200 and $199 a month—$12 apart across a year—for two education memberships covering the same instruments through opposite models. One sells a response to your work; the other sells an archive to work through.
The short answer
Price is a tie. The teaching model is the entire decision.
Both rooms teach options and futures at roughly $2,388 a year. Jdub is built around a coaching loop—course, live sessions, daily reviews, and personalized feedback on work you submit. RakeTrades is built around a library—a Mastermind sequence, 500+ trade reviews, watchlists, and a key-levels indicator. Pick the one that matches how you actually study.
You study independently and want a sequenced course plus a large reviewable archive. It rewards a member who follows an order; it punishes one who browses.
View RakeTrades offer ↗Commission link| Community | Best for | Price | 12-month cost | Rating | Public audience | Actions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| JTJdub TradesOptions + Futures | Learners who want courses, live trading, and feedback together. | $200/month | $2,400at listed cadence | 4.90 ★509 reviews | 17.7K joined | Check price ↗Commission link |
| RTRakeTradesFutures + Options | Futures and options learners who want a large course archive, trade reviews, and psychology tools. | $199/month | $2,388at listed cadence | 5.00 ★360 reviews | 442 members | Check price ↗Commission link |
Teaching model
A feedback loop versus a study library.
Jdub's public offer centers a full course, live options and futures trading, daily reviews, a tool called Scarface, and personalized feedback—a structure closer to an ongoing coaching program than a static product. RakeTrades packages a futures-and-options Mastermind with more than 500 trade reviews and bonus lessons, daily watchlists, weekly newsletters, a key-levels TradingView indicator, and a psychology tool. The practical test is honest and unflattering: will you submit work and act on a reply, or will you complete a sequence on your own? Buying the model you wish you used is the expensive mistake here.
Audience figures
These two numbers do not measure the same thing.
Jdub displays 17,666 joined; RakeTrades displays 442 members. That looks like a decisive gap and mostly is not one. The Jdub figure is storefront-wide and includes free products, while the RakeTrades figure is a product-level count shown on the premium listing itself. A storefront total and a paid-product total are different categories of number, and comparing them directly overstates the difference. Ask each operator for current paid membership if scale matters to you.
Review distribution
The higher rating gives you less to read.
RakeTrades shows 5.0 ★ from 360 reviews—97% five-star with a single critical rating. Jdub shows 4.9 ★ from 509, about 90% five-star with a visible minority of one-star reviews, including a support-consistency concern involving a team member other than Jdub. The counterintuitive read: the marginally lower rating carries more usable information. A near-perfect distribution leaves little critical text, which limits what you can learn about churn, refund disputes, and poor-fit buyers before paying.
Published terms
One states its refund policy; the other leaves it to checkout.
The Jdub FAQ says there are no refunds and that members can cancel at any time—unwelcome, but stated plainly, and “cancel anytime” stops renewal rather than returning money. The RakeTrades listing displays cancellation and refund FAQ entries without exposing their answers in the public text we could verify, so the terms exist but are not readable before purchase. Neither is disqualifying. They ask for different diligence: with Jdub, decide whether you accept a no-refund purchase; with RakeTrades, capture the written terms at checkout before the first charge.
Use the same diligence
Ask both rooms these six questions.
- Who answersWho provides feedback or support today, and what is the normal response time?
- Course sequenceWhat is the exact module order for a new options student versus a new futures student?
- Archive qualityAre recordings indexed by setup, instrument, and outcome—and do they include losses and no-trade decisions?
- Live scheduleWhich sessions run this week, in what time zone, and what is the replay policy?
- Tool dependenceCan the taught process be executed without the included indicator or tool, and is it covered for the full term?
- Exit termsWhat are the written cancellation and refund terms at checkout, and what happens to access mid-cycle?
Primary sources
Check the live offer before paying.
Facts were checked against the current official marketplace listings on August 15, 2026. Prices, counts, schedules, and terms can change.
Affiliate and risk disclosure
The Intraday may earn a commission if you join either room through a marked link. Commission does not determine the comparison, the order of these rooms, or your price. We reviewed public offer evidence; we did not buy private access, audit member returns, or verify seller performance claims. Marketplace ratings, review counts, and audience figures are platform-reported and are not trading results. Options and futures trading carries substantial risk of loss.